Woman Wonders If She Was Wrong To Ask A Mom And Her Crying Child To Leave A Restaurant

ashleyhyshka | February 6, 2025 2:00 pm

No parent enjoys it when their child suddenly starts crying in a public place. Between drawing the glares of annoyed passersby and wrangling a child who won't listen, it's an embarrassing scenario. But as a parent, what is the proper way to handle this situation?

When one woman's romantic dinner was ruined by a screaming child, she decided to confront the parents, but now, she's wondering if she went too far.

Going Out To A Restaurant

Little girl sits at a table in a restaurant and messily eats pasta.
Photo Credit: Tim Clayton / Corbis via Getty Images
Photo Credit: Tim Clayton / Corbis via Getty Images

When people go out for a bite to eat, they are hoping to spend a couple of hours savoring delicious food and enjoying some peace and quiet.

But anything from a long waiting time to poor service can ruin your mood and what you'd hoped would be a relaxing and indulgent night out. On the list of "things that could go wrong," how high up does a misbehaving child rank?

ADVERTISEMENT

The Reddit Post

ADVERTISEMENT
Table for two at a restaurant that overlooks the city lights below.
Photo Credit: Matthieu Huang / Unsplash
Photo Credit: Matthieu Huang / Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Reddit user Wrong_Ad_3951 posed the question to the AITA subreddit and wanted to know if she was in the wrong for how she reacted to a family whose child wouldn't stop crying while at a restaurant eating dinner.

ADVERTISEMENT

She begins the story by explaining that she and her boyfriend were out to dinner at a nice restaurant one night. While not a Michelin star-type restaurant, the establishment is still known for offering delicious food, and so she and her boyfriend were expecting an enjoyable evening.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Ruined Evening

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Close-up photo of a crying child.
Photo Credit: Marco Aurelio / Unsplash
Photo Credit: Marco Aurelio / Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Partway into the meal, the girlfriend noticed two parents and three children, ranging in age from 2 to 10 years old, a couple of tables over. While they were enjoying their meal, the toddler all of a sudden started shrieking.

ADVERTISEMENT

"When I say shrieking I'm talking about the ear piercing type that is physically painful," she explains. "This goes on for about 10 minutes, and by this point, I'm getting annoyed, since I've paid to enjoy my meal, and the child isn't shutting up."

ADVERTISEMENT

Take The Child Outside

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Blurred photo of a mom holding a baby looking off camera.
Photo Credit: Meghan Holmes / Unsplash
Photo Credit: Meghan Holmes / Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Fed up with the incessant crying, the girlfriend walked over to the family and asked if someone could take the child outside until he calmed down since he was disturbing people's evening. The mother became angry and said her son is only a toddler and she should be compassionate instead.

ADVERTISEMENT

The girlfriend responded that she'd paid good money to enjoy her meal and doubled down by saying she needed to do everyone a favor and take her son outside. After she sat back down, she noticed the mother flag down one of the servers.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Situation Escalated

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
A young boy and girl eating dinner at a family restaurant.
Photo Credit: Mark Peterson / Corbis via Getty Images
Photo Credit: Mark Peterson / Corbis via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

After she got the attention of a server, the mother told them that the girlfriend was terribly rude and was making her uncomfortable. A nearby patron overheard this conversation and told the server that the mom was lying and that she'd allowed her child to cry while other people were trying to eat.

ADVERTISEMENT

"The parents left eventually, but not before shooting me an evil look," she says.

ADVERTISEMENT

Am I The Bad Guy?

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Woman sits on a stool and looks at the camera and shrugs.
Photo Credit: Polina Zimmerman / Pexels
Photo Credit: Polina Zimmerman / Pexels
ADVERTISEMENT

The girlfriend explains that she later told a friend about the incident and that the friend thought she should've been more considerate of the family since parenting is difficult. She responded by saying that they chose to have kids, and so "need to parent them better." But her friend didn't agree with her reasoning.

ADVERTISEMENT

She then asks Reddit, "AITA for asking a mother to leave a restaurant with her crying child?"

ADVERTISEMENT

Taking Accountability

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Reddit comment: THIS 100%I have a 2.5 year old who used to act out in public. Every time he did, we left the place, because were considerate of our surroundings and the other people around us. He doesn't act out as much anymore because he knows that acting out = leaving.Parents need to take accountability for their kids!
Photo Credit: Reddit
Photo Credit: Reddit
ADVERTISEMENT

Reddit voted overwhelmingly in favor of the girlfriend in that she was not at fault, and that she was right to confront the parents for not controlling their child in a public setting.

ADVERTISEMENT

"While being a parent IS difficult, there are still courtesies that need to be followed. Those courtesies include removing a child from a public place if they are not behaving, crying or screaming. This also teaches the child that their actions are not acceptable and that they will lose out on fun if they don't behave."

ADVERTISEMENT

Could've Handled It Better

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Reddit comment: ESH. They should have removed the child, but if you needed to say something you should have done it through a staff member. Not your place to directly confront another paying customer, IMO.
Photo Credit: Reddit
Photo Credit: Reddit
ADVERTISEMENT

However, not everyone was on the girlfriend's side. Some users said that while she was right to be upset, she should have had a manager address the situation instead of trying to parent-shame them herself.

ADVERTISEMENT

"I used to work at a restaurant and have been in restaurants when children have been screaming. It sucks but those parents definitely didn't need you to come over there and tell them that. There are so many better ways to handle the situation."