Man’s Marriage Proposal Ends In Disappointment And Regret

Mason Zimmer | August 28, 2023 6:39 pm

When someone is about to propose to their longtime partner, it's natural for a lot of nervousness to creep in before they pop the question. When a relationship is going well, it's understandable to fear that a big step forward in it will change it forever. And even if the idea of proposing itself doesn't inspire those anxieties, it's easy to second-guess the right way to do it.

However, that's a step that one man apparently didn't take before he went ahead with his proposal. And in the aftermath, one of his friends wondered if her reality check did more harm than good.

A big day ahead

woman with arms around boyfriend's neck
Tim Mossholder/unsplash
Tim Mossholder/unsplash

In a Reddit post, a woman explained that her friend Stephen told her he was planning to propose to his girlfriend of three years, Dina.

And at first, this sounded great to her.

ADVERTISEMENT

They got close quickly

ADVERTISEMENT
couple cuddling in bean bag chair next to guitar in otherwise empty room
Toa Heftiba/unsplash
Toa Heftiba/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

The woman further explained that the couple had met in a bar prior to 2020 and blazed past the talking stage quickly.

ADVERTISEMENT

As they got closer, they eventually moved in together and discussed marriage plans.

ADVERTISEMENT

A supportive friend

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman looking down bashfully amid winter forest
Kelly Sikkema/unsplash
Kelly Sikkema/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Not only does the friend consider them a great match, but she said she's never seen Stephen happier.

ADVERTISEMENT

In her post, she wrote, "He told me that he was planning to propose to Dina, and I was ecstatic."

ADVERTISEMENT

Some bad news

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman tlaking on phone with sullen expression
yang miao/unsplash
yang miao/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

However, when the day of the proposal elapsed and the woman called Stephen to congratulate him, he was not in a celebratory mood.

ADVERTISEMENT

He then broke the news to her that Dina had rejected his proposal.

ADVERTISEMENT

A vague explanation

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
man in baseball cap talking on phone with serious expression
Wout Vanacker/unsplash
Wout Vanacker/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Naturally, this turn of events shocked the woman, and she asked if Dina had given him any indication as to why she said no.

ADVERTISEMENT

In response, he said that she didn't like how he proposed.

ADVERTISEMENT

A bad sign

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
couple cuddling forlornly in nature
kabita Darlami/unsplash
kabita Darlami/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Although Stephen had told the woman about his intentions, he hadn't really discussed his specific plans until that phone call.

ADVERTISEMENT

This meant the woman learned soon after Dina did that he intended to propose where they first met. Since this was a bar, the woman had an inkling that the setting was the problem.

ADVERTISEMENT

She didn't want to assume too much

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
women sitting with highlighter near book
Maria Fernanda Pissioli/unsplash
Maria Fernanda Pissioli/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

But while the woman had her suspicions as to why Dina turned Stephen's proposal down, she wanted to reach out to her privately since they had become close as well.

ADVERTISEMENT

And although it turned out that the location didn't help matters, the problem was more fundamental than that.

ADVERTISEMENT

He refused to listen

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman burying her face in her hands
Julia Taubitz/unsplash
Julia Taubitz/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Dina confided in the woman that she had told Stephen multiple times that she didn't want him to propose to her in public.

ADVERTISEMENT

As the woman continued, "She was horrified he would do it at a bar of all places and that she felt disrespected that he didn't accommodate that."

ADVERTISEMENT

She shared Dina's disappointment

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Woman angrily talking to man with bewilderment
Blake Cheek/unsplash+
Blake Cheek/unsplash+
ADVERTISEMENT

Once she had more context, she got in touch with Stephen and shared her own misgivings about his idea.

ADVERTISEMENT

She said, "I told Stephen that his proposal was honestly really disrespectful and seriously kind of messed up."

ADVERTISEMENT

An unexpected response

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Man strokes chin in simmering anger in booth
Bruce Dixon/unsplash
Bruce Dixon/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Stephen didn't take this well and called her insensitive, adding that she should be supportive as a friend instead of "talking down on him."

ADVERTISEMENT

This exchange led the woman to wonder what she did wrong, so she reached out to Reddit.

ADVERTISEMENT

Shooting the messenger

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman putting hand over her face in exasperation
Jussara Paulo/unsplash
Jussara Paulo/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

The vast majority of commenters didn't see an issue with the woman's handling of the situation, especially in light of how badly Stephen's proposal lined up with Dina's stated feelings.

ADVERTISEMENT

One user said, "This makes me sad because not only did she tell him, but you are, in fact, supporting him by explaining what he did wrong. SO HE CAN FIX IT!"

ADVERTISEMENT

What does he expect?

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman stroknig chin in thoughtful pose
Tachina Lee/unsplash
Tachina Lee/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Another person thought it was worth asking Stephen if he would prefer that the woman lies to him in such cases.

ADVERTISEMENT

The said, "Tell him that you are his friend and that you want him to learn and grow. Let him know that you will now question him as to what kind of support he is looking for, honesty or a shoulder to cry on."

ADVERTISEMENT

Bad memories

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
engagement ring with large diamond in roses
Esther Tuttle/unsplash
Esther Tuttle/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Others saw Stephen's behavior as a red flag, and one woman recounted a story that bolstered this view. In it, she told a now-former boyfriend that she wanted a silver ring with a cheap gemstone rather than a gold one with a diamond due to aesthetic and ethical reasons.

ADVERTISEMENT

But as she relayed, "I did not know that he was planning to propose, but he later handed me a gold ring with a diamond in it, then insisted that I would realize that he was right and eventually accept his proposal"

ADVERTISEMENT

Needless to say, that guy was wrong

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
woman turning her head with her hands out
Priscilla Du Preez/unsplash
Priscilla Du Preez/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Since this ex refused to take the ring back, she ended up selling it on eBay and telling him in no uncertain terms that it was over. Naturally, she was worried Stephen had a similar personality.

ADVERTISEMENT

As she also made a point of saying, "I sent him the link to the auction and offered to return the ring to him at any point until a buyer sent me payment."

ADVERTISEMENT

An unpleasant reminder

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Collage Maker-22-Jun-2023-09-16-AM-8633
Dylan Sauerwein/unsplash | Markus Winkler/unsplash
Dylan Sauerwein/unsplash | Markus Winkler/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Another user shared that they were reminded of all the times they'd seen a big, public proposal at a sporting event. And they didn't see that as a flattering comparison.

ADVERTISEMENT

As this user said, "It would be a NIGHTMARE to be put on the spot like that."

ADVERTISEMENT

A positive way forward

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
nathan-dumlao-wok8ytqf-qM-unsplash
Nathan Dumlao/unsplash
Nathan Dumlao/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Another person joined the chorus of commenters agreeing that the woman did the right thing but also had an idea for what happens after Stephen nurses his wounded pride.

ADVERTISEMENT

As they wrote, "If he needs support and you want to help him, both of which are reasonable, maybe offer to help him plan a more personal private proposal?"

ADVERTISEMENT

A dissenting view

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
freestocks vJvLne0TwI-unsplash
freestocks/unsplash
freestocks/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Although the majority of commenters sided with the woman, that support wasn't universal. Others believed this wasn't any of her business in the first place.

ADVERTISEMENT

As one person expressing this view said, "Why are you inserting yourself into this situation? Be supportive of both, but let them resolve it. Getting in the middle is foolish."

ADVERTISEMENT

In a way, the dissenters were right

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
taylor-deas-melesh-9ru6Vkev-6w-unsplash
Taylor Deas-Melesh/unsplash
Taylor Deas-Melesh/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

In an update to her post, the woman shared that Stephen apparently had a Reddit account she didn't know about and found her post.

ADVERTISEMENT

And when he confronted her about it, he expressed his anger that she "aired their dirty laundry."

ADVERTISEMENT

But in a way, they were also wrong

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
christian-velitchkov-oCD1HUJmFIM-unsplash
Christian Velitchkov/unsplash
Christian Velitchkov/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

But that wasn't all Stephen had to say to her. Because while that anger was real, he also felt compelled to thank the woman for posting what she did.

ADVERTISEMENT

After all, it gave him a chance to see people's comments, which "gave him a different perspective."

ADVERTISEMENT

Things are tense but not unsalvagable

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
getty-images-mzSWAAkViPE-unsplash
Getty Images/unsplash+
Getty Images/unsplash+
ADVERTISEMENT

The woman also updated interested parties on the state of the couple's relationship.

ADVERTISEMENT

And while they were still together at the last report, how long that remains true is contingent on how their efforts to work things out go.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dina's distance

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
tiago-bandeira-mMV4NU3UBY8-unsplash
Tiago Bandeira/unsplash
Tiago Bandeira/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

The woman reported how upset Dina remained in the aftermath of the proposal and spent the days immediately after the incident at her parents' house.

ADVERTISEMENT

But at the same time, she's gone over to the home she shares with Stephen at night to try and work this out.

ADVERTISEMENT

She remains conflicted

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
cheron-james-jxNOPmh-wbQ-unsplash
Cheron James/unsplash
Cheron James/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Dina has told the woman that she's working on forgiving Stephen but still feels disturbed at how blatantly he ignored her wishes.

ADVERTISEMENT

So, for the time being, the couple is not engaged, and Dina doesn't plan to change that anytime soon.

ADVERTISEMENT

Taking the advice to heart

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
disruptivo-vIAGW486ewo-unsplash
ISRUPTIVO/unsplash
ISRUPTIVO/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Clearly, the woman liked the suggestion to help plan a more private proposal in the future.

ADVERTISEMENT

Because she said that if the couple does work things out and stays together, she told Stephen that she's happy to do so.

ADVERTISEMENT

A perfect locale isn't hard to find

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
armen-poghosyan-HxAd7cT_Xrk-unsplash
Armen Poghosyan/unsplash+
Armen Poghosyan/unsplash+
ADVERTISEMENT

Since all three of them live in Florida, they have more than their share of beaches to choose from.

ADVERTISEMENT

So the woman said that if everything ends up going well, she advised Stephen to take her to one in the evening after everyone else has headed back home and pop the question when everything's nice and secluded.

ADVERTISEMENT

Stephen's well aware of his situation

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
getty-images-PJoY0_YAivs-unsplash
Getty Images/unsplash
Getty Images/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

It may not have been clear to Stephen how seriously Dina took her wishes against a public proposal before, but the gravity of his situation is all too clear to him now.

ADVERTISEMENT

And that's reflected in what he has since done with the ring.

ADVERTISEMENT

A symbol of a mistake

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
katelyn-macmillan-X1504kwZTnI-unsplash
Katelyn MacMillan/unsplash
Katelyn MacMillan/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

The woman relayed that Stephen informed Dina of his plan to return the ring he bought, further demonstrating his understanding that another proposal would need some serious time.

ADVERTISEMENT

And there's another element of this decision that's more unorthodox but is nonetheless a gesture to make things right.

ADVERTISEMENT

A token of good faith

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
nini-fromparis-0uL6LmJPecA-unsplash
Nini FromParis/unsplash
Nini FromParis/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Stephen said that after he returns the ring, he plans to give some of the money he gets back to Dina.

ADVERTISEMENT

And that's supposed to be money she's free to do with as she sees fit.

ADVERTISEMENT

Another surprise

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
brooke-cagle-ZuQnhpFjvHI-unsplash
Brooke Cagle/unsplash
Brooke Cagle/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Although the woman isn't 100% certain about this, she also believes Stephen sent flowers to Dina's work.

ADVERTISEMENT

The woman said, "So I guess it all worked out in the end."

ADVERTISEMENT

Up in the air

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
tucker-good--RWTAPMnSHk-unsplash
Tucker Good/unsplash
Tucker Good/unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Although the woman is obviously optimistic about the future of Stephen and Dina's relationship, it would perhaps be more accurate to say things are working out rather than that they have worked out.

ADVERTISEMENT

Still, there are signs that a reconciliation is on the way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Privacy concerns

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
valeria-nikitina-9dEzKnQ653M-unsplash
Valeria Nikitina/unsplash+
Valeria Nikitina/unsplash+
ADVERTISEMENT

But anyone curious about any further updates to this situation will be disappointed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Because — likely out of respect for the couple's privacy — the woman ended up deleting both her original post and the account she made it with.